Cancellation may feel like power in the moment, but absolutism is hard to maintain over time because it eventually exposes its own hypocrisy, confuses moral clarity with moral arrogance, punishes complexity, and boomerangs against the very people who once cheered it on.
Too much of our discourse now begins with one ugly assumption: I am right, you are wrong, and because you are wrong, you deserve and need to be cancelled. Not challenged. Not debated. Not persuaded. Cancelled.
That is not liberalism. That is not progressive. That is not moral courage. In my opinion it is simply soft fascism dressed up in feel-good, politically correct therapeutic language. It does not wear a uniform or march down the street like the Italian Blackshirts or Nazi Brownshirts. Rather, it arrives through accusation, social pressure, institutional panic, and the smug certainty that some people no longer deserve standing because they failed to use the approved words, support the approved cause, or accept the approved truth.
What happened to the idea that liberal thought meant openness? What happened to tolerance? What happened to the supposedly sacred belief in free speech? Somehow, in the name of compassion, we have created a culture where disagreement is treated as violence, discomfort is treated as trauma, and censorship is treated as justice.
Before cheering the next cancellation, ask one uncomfortable question: would you defend the same tactic if it were used against someone on your side? I don’t think so.
Absolutism Is Not a Liberal Value
The first problem is absolutism. If liberal or progressive values are now enforced through public shaming, professional punishment, and social exile, then we should at least be honest about what that is. It is illiberal viewpoints with better branding.
There is a strange hypocrisy in watching people who claim to defend openness become the quickest to shut down speech they dislike. They say they support dialogue, but only after deciding which views are allowed to enter the room. They say they believe in inclusion, but only for people who already agree with them. They say they oppose oppression, while using pressure and fear to make people comply. Sounds like ‘soft-fascism’ to me.
Therein lies the dissonance. A movement cannot claim to be morally superior because it protects speech, then turn around and destroy people for speech. At some point, the contradiction becomes impossible to ignore. This is where absolutism and cancellation begin to crumble under their own conflicts.
Is There Only One Truth?
The second question is whether we have decided there is only one truth. Not truth as in facts, evidence, history, or reality. I mean one socially approved truth that must be repeated without hesitation. This is where cancellation becomes dangerous. It does not simply argue that certain ideas are wrong. It argues that certain ideas are not allowed to be explored. Once that happens, the conversation is no longer a conversation. It becomes a loyalty test. Period! End of Discussion.
And loyalty tests are always unstable. Today’s approved position can become tomorrow’s unforgivable mistake. The same people who use cancellation as a weapon often discover later that the weapon has no loyalty. Eventually, the tide turns. The standards shift. And the language changes. The person who once pointed the finger becomes the one being pointed at. So, be careful of expressing your moral outrage without a healthy dose of personal reflection.
That is the boomerang effect of absolutism. It feels good until it comes back to bite you in the ass.
A society needs moral absolutes. But cancellation is what happens when moral clarity mutates into moral arrogance — when punishment replaces persuasion and accusation becomes a form of status.
What Happened to Two Sides of the Coin?
The expression “two sides of the coin” used to mean something different than how we use it today. It did not mean both sides were always equally correct. It meant human affairs are complicated, motives are mixed, history is layered, and most serious issues deserve more than one permitted sentence.
Now that idea itself seems suspect. To suggest nuance is to risk accusation. To ask for balance is to be told you are excusing harm. To say there may be another angle to understand a situation is treated as proof that you are secretly on the wrong side. That is not only intellectually lazy, it is socially corrosive. Civilized societies require some ability to hear arguments they do not like. Without that, public life becomes a series of competing denunciations. People stop thinking and start performing. They do not ask, “What is true?” They ask, “What am I allowed to say?” Or easily influenced and poorly informed individuals repeat slogans that are in vogue rather than think critically or have the courage to question and disagree.
Context Still Matters
The fourth issue is context. Does context have any meaning anymore in a world where history and precedence are dismissed? Who decides what is contextual? Who gets to interpret intent? And who, if anyone, gets the benefit of the doubt?
Cancellation usually depends on stripping context away. A sentence becomes a verdict. A phrase becomes a life sentence. A bad joke, clumsy comment, old position, or emotionally charged statement becomes the whole person. There is no history, no growth, no complexity, no proportion. Just the screenshot and the sentence: you are done.
That is not justice. It is reduction. And reduction is one of the easiest ways to dehumanize people while pretending to protect humanity.
Not Every Argument Has Equal Weight
To be clear, none of this means every argument deserves equal respect. I am not suggesting that all positions have the same moral weight, intellectual validity, or historical standing. They do not. Societies need some absolutes as the basic building blocks and scaffolding of how we can live together. In fact, the moral and ethical character of a society is partly revealed by the things it is willing to say are not negotiable. These may change over time, and often through bitter public discussion. For example, we reject slavery in this country, just as we reject the industrialized policy of the Nazi’s employed as the Final Solution and the Holocaust of the Jews in Europe. Both were and are evil - Full stop.
That is exactly why moral language has to be used carefully.
When every injustice becomes genocide, when every disagreement becomes violence, when every opponent becomes a fascist, when every white American is marked with the ‘stain’ of being a colonial settler and when every uncomfortable argument becomes harm, the words begin to lose their moral force. Instead of clarifying evil, we dilute it. Instead of honoring history, we turn history into a rhetorical weapon. That is not seriousness. That is virtue signaling that is anything but virtuous.
There is a difference between recognizing a moral absolute and weaponizing absolutism. One reflects ethical clarity. The other reflects arrogance.
If everything is treated as unforgivable, then eventually nothing is truly understood as evil. If every offense warrants cancellation, then punishment becomes less about justice and more about status. Who gets to accuse? Who gets to define the terms? Who gets immunity? Who gets destroyed?
A serious society must be able to say two things at once: some moral lines are real, and not every violation of current ideological fashion belongs on the same side of that line.
When Everyone Makes Up Their Own Facts
The fifth problem may be the most dangerous. What happens when each side makes up its own truth, its own facts, and its own vocabulary? What happens when words like occupation, apartheid, ethnic cleansing, genocide, white settler colonialism, privilege, and oppression are used not to clarify, but to end discussion?
Words matter. They carry moral weight. But when complex ideas are turned into dog-whistle words or phrases they become trite and more dangerously become weapons. They stop helping us understand reality and start helping us punish each other. Every side does it. Every faction has its preferred terms, sacred phrases, forbidden questions, and emotional triggers.
That is how discourse gets off course. It does not just become coarser. It becomes narrower. The road has only one lane. My lane. All other lanes have no right to exist.
In our reality of non-stop election cycles, the candidates that evoke outrage through this cynical and purposeful abuse of language only abet the degradation of our social cohesiveness.
The Long-Run Failure of Cancellation
Cancellation can win the moment. It can get someone fired, disinvited, humiliated, or frightened into silence. But it is hard to maintain over the long run because it creates too many enemies, too much resentment, and too much hypocrisy.
People do not forget being erased. They do not forget being told they are morally defective because they asked the wrong question or refused the fashionable answer. They may go quiet, but quiet is not the same as convinced.
My call to action is not complicated, but it does require some courage: stop outsourcing your judgment to the loudest crowd. Ask what was actually said. Ask whether context matters. Ask whether the punishment fits the offense. Ask whether the people demanding tolerance are practicing any themselves. And most of all, ask whether a society that cannot tolerate disagreement can honestly still call itself free. If not, then it’s just soft fascism with better manners.



